Children’s book awards are valuable resources for librarians looking to add books that have received recognition for their merit to their children’s collection. The Children’s Book Council of Australia (CBCA) runs one such award, hosting the Book of the Year award across six categories. These awards aim to not only recognise the excellence of Australia creatives but strive to enrich the literary experience for children by spotlighting and supporting Australian children’s book authors (CBCA, n.d.).
Opting to write a review from this year’s shortlist, I selected Gymnastica Fantastica by Briony Steward from the Early Childhood category. Considering the prevalence of really childhood programs in libraries it seemed fitting, and the cover of this title caught my eye, leading me to review her delightful picture book that is aimed at ages 3 to 6.

Although I have written countless book reviews before, this was my first time reviewing a picture book. It was a unique challenge, shifting the focus from evaluating only text but examining how the illustrations contributed to the storytelling. Before writing however I needed to research (Embury, 2019; Nespoli, n.d) what was typically included in such a review which included:
- Who does this book appeal to and why?
- How does the artwork contribute to the story and is it well crafted?
- What concepts or meanings are conveyed in the story?
- Are the characters distinct and make an impression?

I kept this in mind while writing my review of Gymnastica Fantastica, which helped me to structure the review and provide useful information to someone who may be considering this book for their child (see appendix A).
The experience was useful, but I wanted to better understand the judging criteria of the early childhood category as well, which is extensive. The key aspects are the way the book has introduced a reader to new concepts and vocabulary through illustration that reflects all the text on each page, with particular attention to how it furthers literacy development (CBCA, 2023, p.13). I do believe this book does this, through highlighting the concept of imperfectness and communicating to children that is okay to not be the best if you’re having fun doing something. In terms of literacy development, the writing is very well done in a rhyming and playful way that will engage children and extend them as new readers.
As I anticipate working in a library focusing on children’s services, evaluating a title from the 2024 award shortlist emphasised the importance of book awards in aiding librarians to discover new additions for their collections, potential for Storytime programs and widening knowledge for readers advisory services. It is even more helpful in the case of Gymnastica Fantastica, who’s publisher has also provided teachers’ notes featuring book ideas and activities that can be adapted to children’s programming to enhance literacy skills, yet another useful tool. This experience prompted me to reflect on the qualities that define a good book – those worth of inclusion in a library collection or recommendation to parents and children. Book awards like these serve as valuable tools in a librarian’s arsenal for discovering and acquiring enriching titles that develop children’s reading journeys. However, it is equally vital for librarians to read these titles themselves to accurately evaluate their suitability for their community While awards serve as valuable aids, they shouldn’t replace you own judgement in the acquisition process.
This is the fourth in a series of reflective blog posts as part of my professional development for university subject INF505 Library Services for Children and Young Adults.
References
Embury, D. (2019, January 20). Reviewing children’s picture books: The 4 key elements.https://thedeborahembury.wordpress.com/2019/01/20/reviewing-childrens-picture-books-the-4-key-elements/
Nespoli, K. P. (n.d.). How to write a picture book review. https://karennespoli.com/how-to-write-a-picture-book-review/#:~:text=Book%20Review%20Basics&text=Simply%20review%20your%20experience%20or,she%20should%20read%20the%20book.
The Children’s Book Council of Australia (CBCA). (n.d.). About the CBCA book of the year awards. https://www.cbca.org.au/about-the-awards
The Children’s Book Council of Australia (CBCA). (2023, March). The CBCA book of the year awards policy [PDF]. https://cbca.blob.core.windows.net/documents/BookOfTheYear/AwardPolicy/2023_CBCA_BOYA_POLICY.pdf
Appendix A: Book Review for Gymnastica Fantastica by Briony Steward.
Gymnastica Fantastica by Briony Steward is a cheerfully colour packed adventure in trying new physical movements and celebrating the confidence in children to showcase their new skills, even when they haven’t yet mastered them, through the eyes of a child practicing gymnastic skills. Nominated for the 2024 CBCA Book of the Year for Early Childhood its clear to see why this vibrant picture book has been selected.
This is a gorgeously engaging book for both children and parents to read, perfect for ages three to six who are starting to develop their reading skills and enjoy a fun rhyming pattern alongside bold and lively illustrations.
The artwork is delightfully fun and whimsical, capturing the magic and joy of the childhood experience of showing off, having fun, and exploring what their body can do. There is immediate energy and excitement from page one thanks to the bright mixed media illustrations that convey each scenes movement with such dynamism.
The writing and rhymes are fun and playful in how they convey the books key message. At its heart Gymnastica Fanastica shows repeatedly that she isn’t the best, she makes mistakes and tumbles, but throughout she is celebrating her own individuality, that having fun and enjoying the activity is the main goal. Totally immersed in her own world, she is freely being herself and having a blast while doing so, much to the bemusement of her dog who watches over her throughout. As the author herself remarks, “it’s about the age of ‘watch this!’, ‘look at me!’ and that charmingly funny but sweet way little people put on wonderfully imperfect shows for whoever will watch them” (Sheadhan-Bright, 2023).
Gymnastica is a hilarious character and one any child could see parts of themselves in. She’s brave, carefree, loud, excitable, and creative. As the judges of the CBCA (2023) awards noted, “the young child’s voice permeates the tight, joyful rhyming text”, and it is a delight to read both quietly and aloud. There is so much wild joy on every page this book will enchant and excite children who read it, perhaps their guardians too. I challenge anyone to read this book and not be left smiling like a child at the end of it, this is a wonderful and easy book to recommend.
References
The Children’s Book Council of Australia (CBCA). (2023). Gymnastica Fantastica. https://www.cbca.org.au/book/gymnastica-fantastica
Sheadhan-Bright, R. (2023). Gymnastica Fantastica Teachers Resources [PDF]. https://cdn.hachette.com.au/resources/9780734421852-teachers-resources.pdf